Jekyll and Hyde - Understanding Giftedness Alongside Twice Exceptionality and Behaviour
By Elaine Hook BA (Hons) - Education Consultant
Aren't we all quirky at times? Can't some of us be obsessive? Don't you find it difficult to
sit still when you are bored? Do you find major changes difficult to deal with sometimes? Are
there people you don't get on with? Do you enjoy being alone sometimes? How many times have
you not understood a joke?
All of us have experienced some, if not all, of the above at some time in our lives – does this
make us Autistic or Gifted or neither? Difficult to answer isn't it?
||Autistic Spectrum Characteristics:
|* Can be good all rounders
||* Difficulty with verbal communication
Be high achievers in one area
||* Difficulty with non-verbal communication
Have high ability but low motivation
||* Tend not to understand gestures
Be badly behaved
||* Misunderstands facial expressions
Quiet introverted, even depressed
||* Tend not to understand tone of voice
|* Good verbal but poor written skills
||* Difficulty with social relationships
|* Have difficulties with social relationships
||* Difficulty in interpersonal play
|* Can disguise their abilities
||* Limited imagination
|* Can appear arrogant
||* Obsessive & repetitive behaviours
|* Can be extremely sensitive
||* Resistant to change in routines
|* Have low self-esteem
||* Lack of creative play
|* Can have obsessive behaviours
|* Have a low attention span
|* Have a quirky sense of humour
|* Often need less sleep than others
|* Can be in danger of not acquiring skills
When we don't understand something it can be scary.
When scared we can make judgements, assumptions and stereotype.
Sometimes this can lead to the wrong conclusions.
As an education consultant on the Helpline at the National Association for Gifted Children I
deal with all the above regularly. Parents call distressed and worried that they're child
being labelled and misunderstood and in some cases they feel being misdiagnosed as having
Autistism, Aspergers Syndrome or other characteristics or tendencies which can be confused
with high ability or giftedness. Most parents I talk with feel, very strongly, this misdiagnosis
is untrue, unfair and at times insulting.
Gifted, highly able (or whatever label we want to decorate it up with) children can be quirky,
have a wacky sense of humour, be perfectionists and have obsessive tendencies. They can also
be very sensitive, deep and have a tendency to view the world differently. They often worry
about intense and difficult situations affecting them and the world and ask question after
question on a subject until they have enough information and answers to satisfy themselves
and feel their questions have been answered adequately. They will often be interested in a
particular subject or toy for weeks on end until they have exhausted the subject or game and
do not need to pursue it further.
Their intellectual skills often do not marry up with their social and emotional skills. The intellectual brain development matures more rapidly than the social and emotional part of the brain so they are often out of sync. A highly able child can often communicate and use language like a teenager or adult but more often than not will tend to have outbursts resembling a toddler or child.
As a parent you will need to arm yourself with as much knowledge as possible to enable you to understand this child and respond accordingly to the different behaviours. When your child is operating in adult mode it is important and appropriate to respond as an adult but when the child is behaving as a toddler or child you need to treat them as a child. There will be times when they want to command the respect of an adult and be given choices and responsibility but they will also need to be a child and play, suck their thumb and have a cuddle! It's a balancing act at all stages of development.
No one ever said parenting was easy and all types of parenting on all levels bring with it a variety of challenges, as does giftedness or high ability. Just as at the lower end of the spectrum of needs we make allowances and adjustments so we need to remember the needs of children at the top end of the spectrum? And within the top end of the spectrum of needs there are a huge variety of needs linked to the personality, genes and life experience of each individual. Each child identified as gifted needs individual attention to ensure their needs are met in line with theirs and their family's vision.
Gifted children can appear very adult, using mature language and reading books well in advance of their chronological age. They often prefer to watch documentaries and the news rather than the latest children's TV. They are usually not comfortable with their peers but prefer much older or younger children or adult company. They can be very misunderstood by many and often find it difficult to
"play" within their chronological age group.
When a bright or able child says to his or her friends in the playground that he want to play
"planets" it can cause isolation. When he then goes on to say that everyone is to choose the planet they want to be and that
"we are going to replicate the Solar system," his peers will not understand, move away and continue with their game. Just as they do not understand him, he will not understand why they would not find this a fun cool game to be involved in. It's right here we may begin to see exclusion, isolation, solitude, loners, name calling and eventually bullying. A gifted or highly able child will tend to play alone or begin to compensate for their high ability in order to comply and
"fit in." They can then start to be the class fool or clown in order to be liked and part of the group. This can then be misunderstood or diagnosed as negative behaviour or in some cases having Autistic or ADHD characteristics or tendencies.
We all have quirks, obsessions, fears, paranoia and different senses of humours but does this
mean we are on the Autistic Spectrum? Maybe it does, maybe we are all a little Autistic? When
an able child discusses debates or communicates on a different level and with a deep sense of
passion and understanding it does not necessarily mean that the child has communication problems
and is socially and emotionally inept. We must be extremely careful not to label and/or
misdiagnose. Why do we not see the beauty and pleasure these wonderful little people add to
our lives and the world? Why are we scared of recognising the ability we have in front of us?
Why are we not encouraging and nurturing their skills and be proud to be blessed in educating
these highly intelligent individuals?
When a child who, at 6 years old, is assessed as performing in many areas as a 12 year old,
we must try to have empathy, understanding and compassion for such parents and share the very
real and important needs of such children. I cannot stress highly enough how scary and
bewildering it can be for some parents to be told the news that their child has high ability
or is indeed gifted. Most parents have had to learn by trial and error or go with their gut
instinct in order to fight their corner and be confident to speak out in order to achieve what
they feel is the very best for the family in order to survive the challenges of raising a very
intelligent child. There could be many times when a parent feels their knowledge or skills
are insufficient to help and support their child, but we must encourage parents and teachers
to engage with each other for the mutual benefit of the child's development and not to its
Discussions and debates are often very challenging for parents and educators, as the able
child tends to think they know best, are right and are infallible. Highly able children
function, a good proportion of the time, way above their chronological age and have difficulty
understanding why they cannot, in the eyes of the adults around them, do certain things due
to the fact that they are not old enough or socially and emotionally mature enough to be safe.
It is important to work hard at obtaining a balance for you, the child and the family.
Appropriate house and ground rules should be agreed between you all, they must be reasonable,
consistent and never change. If necessary write the rules on a white board and hang it somewhere
very accessible to all concerned, e.g. above the breakfast table, on the back of the bedroom
door or on the wall in the loo! For younger children design a praise and reward system that
works for you and the child. You will find you have to adjust the rules and/or the system you
design as able children can very quickly adjust their behaviour to the requirements and then
become bored and eventually start to act up again. Remember what I mentioned before, you have
to keep at least 5 steps ahead of your able child, sometimes 10.
Always praise the positive behaviour and try not to dwell on negatives. Give choices with
consequences, which will create responsibility and ensure you stick to the ground rules.
If they see that you will give in when worn down they will continue to always wear you down
as they will know its worth whining as in time in gets what they want. Highly able children
have more energy, determination and time than we do as adults! The theorist Piaget (1896-1980)
advised that if a child's negative behaviour persists for 7 days it will take at least 14 days
to unlearn the behaviour. Consequently years of learned negative behaviour can take years to
change, be patient and persistent.
Able children love responsibility, so give it appropriately. When your child is behaving
responsibly give praise and thanks; show them how pleased and proud you are of them. When
your able child turns into a toddler, explain that you will have to treat them like a toddler
and discipline them accordingly by sending them to their room or sitting them on the bottom
step of the stairs.
Highly able and gifted children think differently to others. As parents and educators we must
arm ourselves with as much knowledge as possible about "giftedness" in order to understand how
their minds work and then we will be better equipped to support their needs and help them grow
into wonderful highly intelligent human beings who will help shape the world in a variety of
ways for our grandchildren and great grandchildren.
Elaine Hook is an Education Consultant for The National Association for Gifted Children,
Britain. She can be reached at:
firstname.lastname@example.org, Tel: 0845 450 0221